Best Shelter Island Hotels On The Beach
-
Great deal
-
Beach access
Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- Express check-in/ -out
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Outdoor swimming pool
The accommodation is approximately a 15-minute ride from places of worship such as Saint Marys Episcopal Church.
Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- Express check-in/ -out
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Outdoor swimming pool
Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!
The accommodation is approximately a 15-minute ride from places of worship such as Saint Marys Episcopal Church.
-
Private beach
The Pridwin Hotel
- Restaurant
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Steam room
- Pool with view
This Shelter Island hotel boasts a waterfront location within 10 minutes' drive of Greenport Antique Carousel and within 15 minutes' drive of Greenport. Cultural sights in the area include Railroad Museum of Long Island, which is 3.4 km away.
Shelter Island is about a 20-minute drive from The Pridwin.
Active guests will enjoy access to a fitness room and an outdoor swimming pool. A number of activities are offered in the area, such as lawn tennis, table tennis, and billiard.
The Pridwin Hotel
- Restaurant
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Steam room
- Pool with view
The Pridwin Hotel
This Shelter Island hotel boasts a waterfront location within 10 minutes' drive of Greenport Antique Carousel and within 15 minutes' drive of Greenport. Cultural sights in the area include Railroad Museum of Long Island, which is 3.4 km away.
Shelter Island is about a 20-minute drive from The Pridwin.
Active guests will enjoy access to a fitness room and an outdoor swimming pool. A number of activities are offered in the area, such as lawn tennis, table tennis, and billiard.
-
Beach access
Montauk Blue Hotel
- BBQ facilities
-
Car park
US$ 35 per day
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Indoor swimming pool
The hotel lies within 5 minutes' drive of Henry Hank Zebrowski Memorial Park and just near Kirk Park Beach. Guests can visit Sunset Surf Shack, which is merely 450 metres away, and Montauk Racquet Club which is 2.1 km from the Montauk Blue.
Also, the property is about a 10-minute ride from the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach.
Beach facilities at the accommodation include deckchairs, parasols, and towels.
Montauk Blue Hotel
- BBQ facilities
-
Car park
US$ 35 per day
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Indoor swimming pool
Montauk Blue Hotel
The hotel lies within 5 minutes' drive of Henry Hank Zebrowski Memorial Park and just near Kirk Park Beach. Guests can visit Sunset Surf Shack, which is merely 450 metres away, and Montauk Racquet Club which is 2.1 km from the Montauk Blue.
Also, the property is about a 10-minute ride from the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach.
Beach facilities at the accommodation include deckchairs, parasols, and towels.
Shelter Island Hotels on the Beach with Balcony
-
Beach access
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
Wilcox Park is 2.6 km from this hotel, while Artists' Cooperative Gallery of Westerly is 2.3 km away. The 3-star hotel is also within a 400-metre distance of Pawcatuck River.
Nature lovers will enjoy the vicinity of Bumpin Hill, located a 16-minute walk away. The nearby sports attractions include Elm Ridge Golf Course, which is 2.2 km away.
This property boasts a heated pool.
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
Wilcox Park is 2.6 km from this hotel, while Artists' Cooperative Gallery of Westerly is 2.3 km away. The 3-star hotel is also within a 400-metre distance of Pawcatuck River.
Nature lovers will enjoy the vicinity of Bumpin Hill, located a 16-minute walk away. The nearby sports attractions include Elm Ridge Golf Course, which is 2.2 km away.
This property boasts a heated pool.
-
Beach access
Avonlea
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Leisure/ TV room
- Sun terrace
This comfortable hotel boasts a beachfront setting 550 metres from Block Island State Beach. Rodman's Hollow is around 5 minutes' drive from the Avonlea Bed & Breakfast, and Block Island is 2.1 km away.
Also, Old Harbor Historic District is situated 650 metres away. Guests can find Settler's Rock Reef, which is 10 minutes away by car.
You can try fishing at this accommodation.
Avonlea
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Leisure/ TV room
- Sun terrace
Avonlea
This comfortable hotel boasts a beachfront setting 550 metres from Block Island State Beach. Rodman's Hollow is around 5 minutes' drive from the Avonlea Bed & Breakfast, and Block Island is 2.1 km away.
Also, Old Harbor Historic District is situated 650 metres away. Guests can find Settler's Rock Reef, which is 10 minutes away by car.
You can try fishing at this accommodation.
-
Guest favorite
-
Beach access
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
This comfortable hotel has an ideal location 4.9 km from Southaven County Park. The Home2 Suites Yaphank is 38 km from Hampton Bays.
No matter the religion, travellers prefer to visit Middle Island Presbyterian Church, a popular place of worship located within 30 minutes' walk of the hotel.
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven hotel has access to an award-winning beach featuring beach towels. Business and leisure travellers can also make use of conference equipment and a photocopy machine.
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
This comfortable hotel has an ideal location 4.9 km from Southaven County Park. The Home2 Suites Yaphank is 38 km from Hampton Bays.
No matter the religion, travellers prefer to visit Middle Island Presbyterian Church, a popular place of worship located within 30 minutes' walk of the hotel.
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven hotel has access to an award-winning beach featuring beach towels. Business and leisure travellers can also make use of conference equipment and a photocopy machine.
Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island On The Beach
-
Private beach
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Welcome drink
- Spa & wellness centre
- Sun loungers
The bed & breakfast has a scenic setting within a few blocks of Hole In The Wall Beach. You can go to a private beach, which is just 1.1 km from the Inn Niantic.
Guests will also appreciate the vicinity to McCook Point Park, located only a 14-minute walk away. Along with other cultural attractions the Hands-on Children's Educational Museum of Southeastern Connecticut is nestled within reach of the property.
Beach facilities at the hotel include free Wi-Fi access. The accommodation is also convenient for going fishing.
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Welcome drink
- Spa & wellness centre
- Sun loungers
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
The bed & breakfast has a scenic setting within a few blocks of Hole In The Wall Beach. You can go to a private beach, which is just 1.1 km from the Inn Niantic.
Guests will also appreciate the vicinity to McCook Point Park, located only a 14-minute walk away. Along with other cultural attractions the Hands-on Children's Educational Museum of Southeastern Connecticut is nestled within reach of the property.
Beach facilities at the hotel include free Wi-Fi access. The accommodation is also convenient for going fishing.
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
The inn is situated near an entertainment district 10 minutes by car from Deep Hollow Ranch. This 3-star hotel is 2.6 km from Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course.
15 minutes by car from the Kenny'S Tipperary Inn, guests will also find the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach.
The Kenny'S Tipperary Inn Montauk welcomes guests to enjoy a picnic area and a golf course provided on-site. This property features diving, boating, and cycling.
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
The inn is situated near an entertainment district 10 minutes by car from Deep Hollow Ranch. This 3-star hotel is 2.6 km from Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course.
15 minutes by car from the Kenny'S Tipperary Inn, guests will also find the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach.
The Kenny'S Tipperary Inn Montauk welcomes guests to enjoy a picnic area and a golf course provided on-site. This property features diving, boating, and cycling.
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Outdoor swimming pool
The comfortable hotel has a prime setting 2.4 km from Elm Ridge Park, while natural sights like Riverfront Park are 4.9 km away. The Holiday Inn Express is also within a 400-metre distance of Great Meadow Shopping Center and within a 10-minute drive of Hang-Dog Hill.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to Sunny Crest Park, situated about 25 minutes' walk away. Along with other cultural attractions Welles-Turner Memorial Library is nestled within 6 km of this accommodation.
A seasonal outdoor pool, a fitness centre are available at the Holiday Inn Express Rocky Hill. Those on a business trip will benefit from a desk and a photocopy machine provided on site.
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Outdoor swimming pool
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
The comfortable hotel has a prime setting 2.4 km from Elm Ridge Park, while natural sights like Riverfront Park are 4.9 km away. The Holiday Inn Express is also within a 400-metre distance of Great Meadow Shopping Center and within a 10-minute drive of Hang-Dog Hill.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to Sunny Crest Park, situated about 25 minutes' walk away. Along with other cultural attractions Welles-Turner Memorial Library is nestled within 6 km of this accommodation.
A seasonal outdoor pool, a fitness centre are available at the Holiday Inn Express Rocky Hill. Those on a business trip will benefit from a desk and a photocopy machine provided on site.
Pet Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island on The Beach
-
Private beach
Winnapaug Inn
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Pool with view
The bronze Statue of Ninigret is located 6 km from this comfortable hotel, and Dunes Park Beach is 2.8 km away. The Winnapaug Inn gives access to a private beach, which is about 20 minutes' walk away.
Misquamicut Beach can also be found 3.9 km from the property.
An outdoor swimming pool, a fitness centre are available at this Westerly hotel. The accommodation is also convenient for going canoeing.
Winnapaug Inn
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Pool with view
Winnapaug Inn
The bronze Statue of Ninigret is located 6 km from this comfortable hotel, and Dunes Park Beach is 2.8 km away. The Winnapaug Inn gives access to a private beach, which is about 20 minutes' walk away.
Misquamicut Beach can also be found 3.9 km from the property.
An outdoor swimming pool, a fitness centre are available at this Westerly hotel. The accommodation is also convenient for going canoeing.
-
Best-rated
-
Private beach
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Saltwater pool
The centre of Shelter Island Heights can be reached in 15 minutes' walk of the boutique-style hotel, and such cultural venues as Nova Constellatio Gallery are 3.4 km away. The Seven is a 15-minute ride from Railroad Museum of Long Island and 30 minutes' drive from Montauk.
The private beach is located 1.3 km away. Greenport Antique Carousel can also be found a 20-minute drive from this property.
This accommodation has a sunbathing terrace, a picnic area, and a golf course, along with swimming pool toys. A range of activities such as boating, hiking, and cycling are offered on the premises.
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Saltwater pool
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
The centre of Shelter Island Heights can be reached in 15 minutes' walk of the boutique-style hotel, and such cultural venues as Nova Constellatio Gallery are 3.4 km away. The Seven is a 15-minute ride from Railroad Museum of Long Island and 30 minutes' drive from Montauk.
The private beach is located 1.3 km away. Greenport Antique Carousel can also be found a 20-minute drive from this property.
This accommodation has a sunbathing terrace, a picnic area, and a golf course, along with swimming pool toys. A range of activities such as boating, hiking, and cycling are offered on the premises.
-
Beach access
The Niantic Inn
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Garden area
If you are in love with sports, the hotel offers a beachfront location around 7 km from Cedar Ridge Golf Course. Niantic is 16 minutes' walk away, and Newport is 77 km from The Niantic Inn.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to McCook Point Park, situated 350 metres away. Rocky Neck State Park is approximately 10 minutes by car from this accommodation.
Guests are welcome to join winery tours arranged by this Niantic hotel.
The Niantic Inn
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Garden area
The Niantic Inn
If you are in love with sports, the hotel offers a beachfront location around 7 km from Cedar Ridge Golf Course. Niantic is 16 minutes' walk away, and Newport is 77 km from The Niantic Inn.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to McCook Point Park, situated 350 metres away. Rocky Neck State Park is approximately 10 minutes by car from this accommodation.
Guests are welcome to join winery tours arranged by this Niantic hotel.
-
Beach access
Sun And Sound Montauk
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Vending machines
- Seasonal outdoor pool
The 3-star hotel is in a beach area of Montauk. Gosman's Dock is within a 500-metre distance of the Sun And Sound Montauk, and Montauk Point State Park is a 15-minute drive away.
Nature lovers will appreciate the vicinity of Montauk Harbor, which is 0.8 km away. Options for cultural tourism include Second House Museum, situated a 20-minute ride away.
The hotel provides guests with entertainment activities such as film nights.
Sun And Sound Montauk
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Vending machines
- Seasonal outdoor pool
Sun And Sound Montauk
The 3-star hotel is in a beach area of Montauk. Gosman's Dock is within a 500-metre distance of the Sun And Sound Montauk, and Montauk Point State Park is a 15-minute drive away.
Nature lovers will appreciate the vicinity of Montauk Harbor, which is 0.8 km away. Options for cultural tourism include Second House Museum, situated a 20-minute ride away.
The hotel provides guests with entertainment activities such as film nights.
-
Private beach
Breezeway Boutique Hotel
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
The hotel is in a beach area of Westerly. There is Winnapaug Golf Course within 2 km of the Breezeway Boutique Westerly.
A private beach is within 5 minutes' drive of the accommodation, while Napatree Point Nature Preserve is situated approximately a 10-minute ride away. Travellers with children will enjoy being near the summertime Bayview Fun Park, which is about 2.1 km away.
This Westerly hotel invites guests to a games room for their enjoyment.
Breezeway Boutique Hotel
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
Breezeway Boutique Hotel
The hotel is in a beach area of Westerly. There is Winnapaug Golf Course within 2 km of the Breezeway Boutique Westerly.
A private beach is within 5 minutes' drive of the accommodation, while Napatree Point Nature Preserve is situated approximately a 10-minute ride away. Travellers with children will enjoy being near the summertime Bayview Fun Park, which is about 2.1 km away.
This Westerly hotel invites guests to a games room for their enjoyment.
-
Popular choice
-
Private beach
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
This beachfront hotel is nestled within a 700-metre distance of Fort Pond. Saint Therese of Lisieux Church is just steps from the Royal Atlantic Beach, while Montauk bus stop is approximately 5 minutes' walk away.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to Kirk Park, situated 450 metres away. There is Hither Woods Preserve Park 4.1 km from this accommodation.
There is private access to a long beach with free Wi-Fi. You can play tennis at this Montauk hotel.
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
This beachfront hotel is nestled within a 700-metre distance of Fort Pond. Saint Therese of Lisieux Church is just steps from the Royal Atlantic Beach, while Montauk bus stop is approximately 5 minutes' walk away.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to Kirk Park, situated 450 metres away. There is Hither Woods Preserve Park 4.1 km from this accommodation.
There is private access to a long beach with free Wi-Fi. You can play tennis at this Montauk hotel.
-
Private beach
The Hotel Maria
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Valet parking
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Sun terrace
The centre of Westerly can be reached within a 10-minute walk, and natural attractions like Watch hill beach are about a 10-minute drive away. When staying at The Hotel Maria Westerly, you'll be 4.2 km from the restored Flying Horse Carousel.
The private beach is located nearly a 5-minute walk away. There is the longtime Atlantic Beach Park merely 1.7 km away.
The property’s a massage treatment will ensure a nice stay.
The Hotel Maria
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Valet parking
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Sun terrace
The Hotel Maria
The centre of Westerly can be reached within a 10-minute walk, and natural attractions like Watch hill beach are about a 10-minute drive away. When staying at The Hotel Maria Westerly, you'll be 4.2 km from the restored Flying Horse Carousel.
The private beach is located nearly a 5-minute walk away. There is the longtime Atlantic Beach Park merely 1.7 km away.
The property’s a massage treatment will ensure a nice stay.
-
Private beach
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Steam room
- Sun terrace
The hotel is a great place to stay due to its beachfront location in Greenport. Lavender By the Bay Farm is nearly 10 minutes' drive away, and East Hampton is 22 km from Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows.
The area also includes natural sites like Sylvester Manor Educational Farm, which are 3.7 km from the property.
At the Silver Sands Greenport, guests are offered yoga instruction and bicycles to stay in shape. This accommodation features canyoning, boating, and hiking for sport lovers.
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Steam room
- Sun terrace
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
The hotel is a great place to stay due to its beachfront location in Greenport. Lavender By the Bay Farm is nearly 10 minutes' drive away, and East Hampton is 22 km from Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows.
The area also includes natural sites like Sylvester Manor Educational Farm, which are 3.7 km from the property.
At the Silver Sands Greenport, guests are offered yoga instruction and bicycles to stay in shape. This accommodation features canyoning, boating, and hiking for sport lovers.
-
Beach access
Sea Crest
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Tennis court
- Outdoor swimming pool
This 3-star resort is a great place to stay due to its oceanfront location in Amagansett. Guests can go to East Hampton, which is a 15-minute drive from the Sea Crest.
Nature lovers will appreciate the vicinity of Napeague Harbor, which is about 20 minutes' walk away. Options for cultural tourism include Victor D'Amico Institute of Art, situated 2.6 km away.
A shared lounge and grills are available at the Sea Crest Amagansett. Guests can work out in a fitness area during their stay.
Sea Crest
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Tennis court
- Outdoor swimming pool
Sea Crest
This 3-star resort is a great place to stay due to its oceanfront location in Amagansett. Guests can go to East Hampton, which is a 15-minute drive from the Sea Crest.
Nature lovers will appreciate the vicinity of Napeague Harbor, which is about 20 minutes' walk away. Options for cultural tourism include Victor D'Amico Institute of Art, situated 2.6 km away.
A shared lounge and grills are available at the Sea Crest Amagansett. Guests can work out in a fitness area during their stay.
Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Beach Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| The Pridwin Hotel |
8.5 / 10 (61 Reviews) |
From 334$ | |
| Montauk Blue Hotel |
8.9 / 10 (465 Reviews) |
From 130$ | |
| La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area |
8.5 / 10 (410 Reviews) |
From 79$ | |
| Avonlea |
9.8 / 10 (94 Reviews) |
From 209$ | |
| Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven |
9.1 / 10 (532 Reviews) |
From 195$ |